10 Biggest Multifamily Investing Mistakes (2025)
Zig Ziglar once said:
“Some of us learn from other people’s mistakes, and the rest of us have to be other people.”
The truth? Making mistakes when investing in real estate can be expensive. The good news is, you don’t have to repeat them.
Over my 40+ years as a multifamily investor, educator, and coach, I’ve seen just about every mistake in the book (and yes, I’ve made some myself). The good news is, if you learn from others, you can shortcut decades of pain and jump right into success. So if you’re asking yourself how to avoid apartment investing mistakes, then you’ve come to the right article.
In this post, I’ll walk you through the 10 biggest mistakes to avoid when you start your multifamily investing journey.
Multifamily investing is not a solo sport.
You need a team:
Brokers to find properties
Lenders to finance deals
Real estate attorneys to protect you in contracts
Property managers to run day-to-day operations
Mentors to help you avoid landmines
Try to go at it alone, and you’re setting yourself up for costly mistakes.
Action Step: Start building your investing team before you purchase your first multifamily property.
So many new multifamily investors think: “I’ll find a deal first, then raise the money.” Wrong.
By the time you chase down partners or investors, the deal is gone.
Action Step: Build relationships with investors, lenders, and potential partners now before you need them. When the right property shows up, you’ll be ready to move fast.
Fear kills deals. Many new investors hesitate, second-guess themselves, or drown in analysis paralysis.
Action Step: Define your investment criteria (location, number of units, returns, risk tolerance). When a deal matches, move. Don’t wait for “perfect.” In real estate, done beats perfect every time.
On the flip side, rushing is just as dangerous. Skipping due diligence, ignoring property inspections, or trusting the seller’s numbers can cost you tens of thousands.
Action Step: Learn to move with cheetah speed; fast but not reckless. Move quickly on the opportunity, but slow down for the underwriting and inspections.
One of the most common mistakes I see is new investors chasing shiny objects. A flashy listing, a “too-good-to-be-true” off-market deal, or a seller promising big profits can attract beginners. They take the first “good deal” they find. But they forget to ask the most important question: Does this property fit my strategy?
Here’s the danger:
You may end up with a property that’s the wrong size or class for your experience level.
You may buy into a market that doesn’t support your growth goals.
You may get stuck managing a property that eats more time, money, and energy than it ever gives back.
I’ve seen new investors buy C-class properties in tough areas. They really wanted a Class B property in a growing market. Others chase luxury deals that look sexy on paper but don’t cash flow.
Action Step: Define your buy box before you shop. Ask yourself:
Am I focused on my local market, or am I open to investing out of state?
Do I want stabilized assets with predictable income, or value-add deals with renovation upside?
Am I looking for workforce housing, Class B, or Class A properties?
When you know your lane, you’ll recognize the right deal immediately and avoid the wrong ones that can sink you.
New investors often bring a single-family mindset into multifamily. They think, “I’ll buy low and sell high once the market appreciates.” That’s speculation, not investing.
Multifamily real estate is an income-producing business first and foremost. Rents pay the bills. Cash flow provides stability. Appreciation happens, but it’s a byproduct of strong operations and market fundamentals and not a guarantee.
When you gamble on appreciation, you set yourself up for disappointment. Economic cycles shift, interest rates rise, and local markets soften. If you’re banking on selling high five years from now, you’re not investing, you’re guessing.
Action Step: Focus on properties that cash flow today. Appreciation is the icing on the cake, not the cake itself. Buy deals where the numbers work now, even if rent growth stalls or cap rates expand. If appreciation comes, fantastic! You’ve just multiplied your returns. But never build your business plan on hope.
Another rookie trap is buying negative cash flow properties with the belief that “it’ll turn around later.” This is dangerous thinking. Unless you have deep pockets, one unexpected expense can wipe you out.
Here’s why: multifamily expenses add up faster than you think. It’s not just your mortgage payment—you’ve got:
Property taxes (which often rise after purchase)
Insurance premiums (especially in today’s market)
Utilities and maintenance (both predictable and unexpected)
CapEx reserves (big-ticket items like roofs, HVAC, and plumbing)
Management fees
If you ignore these in your spreadsheets and assume future rent growth will “fix it,” you’re gambling, not investing.
Action Step: Buy properties that make financial sense from day one. Run conservative underwriting with realistic vacancy, expense, and rent assumptions. Future upside is a bonus, but never hinge your success on it.
Smart investors know: cash flow is freedom. It gives you staying power, it covers you during downturns, and it builds long-term wealth.
Every state, county, and city has landlord-tenant laws. Ignoring them or worse, not knowing them, can land you in court and destroy your returns.
Action Step: Educate yourself or lean on an experienced attorney. Ignorance is not a defense.
I’ve personally made this mistake and survived, but new investors often don’t. The wrong manager will bleed you dry with poor tenant screening, missed maintenance, and bad reporting.
Action Step: Vet managers like your financial life depends on it, because it does. Ask for references, review systems, and trust your gut.
Too many rookies assume existing leases are “fine.” Then they discover sweetheart deals, free parking, or concessions that crush their NOI.
Action Step: Review every lease with your attorney or manager. Don’t inherit someone else’s mistakes.
Here’s the truth: every one of these multifamily investing mistakes is 100% avoidable.
If you surround yourself with the right people, take time to learn the business, and take massive action, you’ll sidestep the traps that take down most beginners.
Don’t dabble. Decide.
Don’t speculate. Cash flow.
Don’t go it alone. Build your team.
That’s how you dominate in multifamily investing.
The biggest mistakes new real estate investors make are:
Each one can cost you thousands, but they’re all 100% avoidable if you learn the business and surround yourself with the right team.
The key is education and preparation. Define your investment criteria, build your team, raise money before chasing deals, and always focus on cash flow first. Pair that with a mentor or coach who’s already been where you want to go, and you’ll collapse time frames and sidestep the landmines that take out most beginners.
Absolutely. Multifamily is one of the strongest asset classes in real estate investing. Even in shifting economies, apartments provide consistent demand, steady income, and strong appreciation opportunities. In 2025, with higher interest rates and evolving markets, the investors who know how to find deals, raise capital, and manage properties are positioned for massive success.
You can figure it out alone but it’s the long, expensive road. A good coach or mentor accelerates your learning, helps you avoid costly mistakes, and holds you accountable. In fact, I credit much of my success to the mentors I had along the way. If you want to go faster and further, find someone who’s already walked the path.
Start with education. Learn how to underwrite deals, raise capital, and build relationships with brokers, lenders, and property managers. From there, set clear goals and take consistent action. Attending a multifamily seminar/webinar or joining a structured coaching program can give you the proven blueprint to confidently take your first deal down.
Join me at the next Multifamily Bootcamp and learn how to find, fund, and close your first (or next) deal.
Or if you’re ready to truly scale, check out my coaching program where we help new and seasoned investors avoid these mistakes, build passive income, and achieve true financial freedom.
The truth is, for 99.99% of Americans your identity has already been stolen. The question should really be: are you...
I’m a big picture thinker, especially when it comes to my finances. I’d rather not be spending my time thinking...
In 2023, Tray Wiltse and the founding team of Integrated Wealth in Overland Park, Kan., had found a buyer they...
